Shown as “Absconding” While in Jail: Bombay High Court Orders ₹2 Lakh Compensation for Violation of Articles 21 and 22
The case in brief
The Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court has directed the Maharashtra Government to pay ₹2 lakh as compensation to Mr. Arun Ferreira. The police had told the court in a 2011 case, in which he was alleged to be a Naxal, that he was absconding. At that time he was actually in jail.
What happened
In its submission in the 2011 case, the police described Mr. Ferreira as an absconding accused. Mr. Ferreira was in judicial custody throughout this period, and the police’s own records could have shown it.
What the Court said
A Division Bench of Justice Urmila Joshi Phalke and Justice Raj Wakode reprimanded the police for this conduct. The Bench held that the police had violated Mr. Ferreira’s fundamental rights under Article 21 and Article 22 of the Constitution. It ordered the State of Maharashtra to pay him ₹2 lakh.
Why Articles 21 and 22 matter
Article 21 guarantees that no person shall be deprived of life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law. Showing a person in custody as absconding is more than a clerical error. It can prejudice his case, damage his reputation and distort the court’s view of his conduct.
Article 22 gives protection to persons arrested and detained, including the right to be informed of the grounds of arrest, to consult a lawyer and to be produced before a magistrate. These safeguards depend on the police keeping honest and accurate records of who is in custody and where.
Compensation as a remedy
The Supreme Court held in Rudul Sah v. State of Bihar (1983) that courts can award monetary compensation under Articles 32 and 226 when the State violates a person’s fundamental rights. D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal (1997) later reinforced this in the context of custodial abuse. The present order follows the same principle: when the State’s agencies violate Article 21, the State is answerable in money as well as in law.
Takeaway
The order is a reminder that police records filed in court are not a formality. A false statement, even a careless one, can cost a person his liberty and dignity, and the State will have to answer for it.
Source: Based on a report in The Hindu