Introduction :-

Chapter VIII of wages code, 2019 is providing laws related to the offences and penalties. Section (52) to Section (56) are sections provides offences and penalties. Section (52) provides cognizance of offences, Section (53) provides power of officers of appropriate government to impose penalty in certain cases, Section (54) provides penalties for offences, Section (55) provides offences by companies, Section (56) provides composition of offences.

The code specifies penalties for offences committed by an employer, such as (i) paying less than the due wages or (ii) for contravening any provision of the code. Penalties vary depending on the nature of offence, with the maximum penalty being imprisonment for three month with a fine of up to one lakh rupees.

Importance of Topic :-

The current framework prescribes the penalties upon non-compliance of the provisions of the concerned legislations. The penalties provided under these statutes are mostly in the nature of fines combined with imprisonment in respect of offences committed by an employer.

A major step has been undertaken in the code to decriminalized majority of the offences by making the penalties monetary in nature. However, it specifies that an employer shall be penalized with imprisonment upon subsequent or repeated violation of an offence under the code within a span of 5 years.

Earlier offences and penalties were spread across four different Act. This code is formed by amalgamation of that Acts. This wage code which universalizes/guarantees minimum wages and timely payment of wages is available to 50 crore workers of organized and unorganized sectors.

The enactment of the code is one of the most progressive steps taken by the Indian Government in terms of reforming the labour law regime. The code has been drafted with the intent to render ease to employer's community by reducing compliance burden. Penalties can deter people from committing offences. Penalties is a form of justice.

Provisions under Chapter VIII of The code on Wages, 2019

  1. Section (52)(1) bars court to take cognizance of any offence, and rests the matter with the authority appointed by the appropriate Government. Section 52(2) bars inferior courts below Metropolitan Magistrate or Judicial Magistrate of the first class, to try an offence.

  2. Section 53, provides powers to officers of appropriate Government to impose penalty in certain cases. This officer is not below of rank of Secretary under Government of India or an officer of equivalent rank in the State Government.

  3. Section 54, Defines penalties for offences. Section 54 subsection 1(a) says if employee paid less amount then punishable with fine upto fifty thousand rupees.

2(a) of section 54 is for repeat offence within five years from the date of the commission of the first offence, is punishable with three months imprisonment or fine up to one lakh rupees, or with both.

  1. Section 55, penalizes offences by companies. It states that every person who, at the time the offence was committed was in charge of, and was responsible to the company for the conduct of business of the company.

  1. Section 5 of the code on wages, 2019 deals with the composition of offenses and the compounding of offenses by a Gazette officer.

It is worthwhile to note that labour codes had received the approval of both houses of the parliament as well as Hon'ble President's assent in 2019 and 2020 and the draft central rules on all the four labour codes have already been pre-published by the central Government. As labour is concurrent subject. Many States and Union territories had also published the state level draft rules for all four or few of the labour codes. However, the final notification of making these codes effective is something which has been on the anvil for some time now.

Case Laws :-

As implementation of New wage is still latest there are not much cases to recognise. But,

Section - 22(A) of Minimum Wages Act, 1948 is in accordance with Section-54 of the code on Wages, 2019.

Champak Lal Thakkar Vs State of Gujrat, Moni Vegetable products Ltd and Its managing Director and Secretary were prosecuted under Section 22-A of Minimum wages Act. for their failure to maintain certain documents which were required to be maintained under 18 of this Act. The prosecution was possible only when the Act applied to mill manufacturing Vanspati. i.e Vanspati oil is included in the "oil mill" list. As oil word was not defined in the Act. meaning of Vanspati oil is taken as "oil" only and Hence, the prosecution of the petitioners under Section 22-A was possible.

Workmen of the Bombay Port Trust Vs Trustees of the port of Bombay, AIR 1962 SC 481This case held that Tribunal cannot allow any additional payement as penalty under section 22-A of Minimum wages Act.Section 22-C i.e offences by companies is in accordance with Section-55 of the wages code, 2019.

Haricharan Singh Dugal and ors. Vs State of Bihar [(1990) 1 LLJ 310 (Patana)]
It was held that section 22-C of Minimum wages Act, 1948 is in pari materia with section 10 of Essential Commodities Act and therefore Directors of a company can be prosecuted, if the violation is committed.Section 28 & 29 of The payment of Bonus Act, 1965 is in accordance with Section-55 of wages code 2019.

In V.B Sivalingam Chettiar, Managing Director Abirami cotton mills Ltd. Sullurpet V/S State represented by labour officer, Nellore [(1986) II LLJ 104 (AP)]
It was held that prosecution is not possible against only one Director and not accused company, and every person at the time of offence in charge is to be prosecuted.

and

In B.K Madhavan Bank of Thanjavur Ltd. V/s State represented by the Labour Enforcement officer (central).[(1989) I LLJ 149 (Madras)]
It was held that although some of the parties not mentioned can be cured as technical defect. The proceedings can not be quashed on such a technical flaw which is curable.

Conclusion :-

The code on Wages, 2019 is still amended and modified by the parliament from time to time. This code has made it easier to amalgamate previous four Act which were dealing with the wages.

References :-

  1. Bare Act: Wages Code, 2019.

  2. Labour and Industrial laws by Avtar Singh & Harpreet Kaur.